Announcement: Power TAC server and sample broker version 1.3.3

classic Classic list List threaded Threaded
12 messages Options
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|  
Report Content as Inappropriate

Announcement: Power TAC server and sample broker version 1.3.3

grampajohn
Administrator
Dear colleagues -

Today I completed the release of the Power TAC server, broker-core, and logtool-core version 1.3.3. Release notes and download links are on the wiki. This is the version that ran the final round of the 2016 tournament. It does not include a working version of the new visualizer used in the tournament, because we are still working on the best way to package it. It also does not include the fix for Issue #882, which deals with the fact that some brokers were being charged for capacity during intervals when they had no tariff transactions.

We have already deployed the first snapshot in the 1.4.0 series, including a fix for #882. We may decide to do one additional point release to the 1.3 series to include this fix also.

John
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|  
Report Content as Inappropriate

Re: Announcement: Power TAC server and sample broker version 1.3.3

serkan
Hi John,

I trade in the balancing market through offering some capacity to DU. I can receive clearing messages (via a BalancingControlEvent object). However, those transactions are not added to cash position. Is it intentionally so or?

Only transactions (PRODUCE for up regulation and CONSUME for down regulation) between customers and broker are added to the cash position.

Best regards.
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|  
Report Content as Inappropriate

Re: Announcement: Power TAC server and sample broker version 1.3.3

grampajohn
Administrator
Hello, Serkan -
serkan wrote
I trade in the balancing market through offering some capacity to DU. I can receive clearing messages (via a BalancingControlEvent object). However, those transactions are not added to cash position. Is it intentionally so or?
I've created Issue #889 to test and correct this problem. Is there a specific game where this problem shows up in the log? If so, could you tell me where to look?

Thanks!

John
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|  
Report Content as Inappropriate

Re: Announcement: Power TAC server and sample broker version 1.3.3

serkan
Probably it happened in all AgentUDE involved games. But I discovered the problem in my local server.

Following is a sample from the log:

Note that my customers are captive here (up and down regulation set to 0.0 in the tariff).
Server version is 1.4.0-SNAPSHOT

10005:org.powertac.common.CashPosition::9800::-rr::361::-1844.3418966807567
10005:org.powertac.common.msg.DistributionReport::9803::-rr::361::38068.69149132358::7139.92
10227:org.powertac.common.MarketPosition::200000031::new::0::385::0.0
10228:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000032::new::0::200000027::0.3::0.2
10228:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000033::new::0::200000027::-0.3::-0.2
14781:org.powertac.common.TimeService::null::setCurrentTime::2009-10-25T02:00:00.000Z
14906:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingControlEvent::12914::-rr::200000027::-2254.902868189027::-11.938700675521495::362
14924:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::12524::-rr::362::CONSUME::3968::1::-0.0::0.0::false
14924:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::12527::-rr::362::CONSUME::3974::1::-0.0::0.0::false
14925:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::12530::-rr::362::CONSUME::3980::1::-0.0::0.0::false
14925:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::12533::-rr::362::CONSUME::3986::1::-0.0::0.0::false
14926:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::12910::-rr::362::CONSUME::3968::1::-563.7257170472567::-0.0::true
14927:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::12911::-rr::362::CONSUME::3974::1::-563.7257170472567::-0.0::true
14927:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::12912::-rr::362::CONSUME::3980::1::-563.7257170472567::-0.0::true
14928:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::12913::-rr::362::CONSUME::3986::1::-563.7257170472567::-0.0::true
14928:org.powertac.common.DistributionTransaction::12918::-rr::362::4::0::0.0::-0.06
14930:org.powertac.common.CashPosition::12920::-rr::362::-1844.4018966807566
14931:org.powertac.common.msg.DistributionReport::12923::-rr::362::44719.92465176833::7069.37
15248:org.powertac.common.MarketPosition::200000034::new::0::386::0.0
15249:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000035::new::0::200000027::0.3::0.2
15249:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000036::new::0::200000027::-0.3::-0.2
19781:org.powertac.common.TimeService::null::setCurrentTime::2009-10-25T03:00:00.000Z
19858:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingControlEvent::15972::-rr::200000027::-1173.8337434628047::-16.48389133729018::363
19880:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::15582::-rr::363::CONSUME::3968::1::-0.0::0.0::false
19881:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::15585::-rr::363::CONSUME::3974::1::-0.0::0.0::false
19882:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::15588::-rr::363::CONSUME::3980::1::-0.0::0.0::false
19884:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::15591::-rr::363::CONSUME::3986::1::-0.0::0.0::false
19884:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::15968::-rr::363::CONSUME::3968::1::-293.4584358657012::-0.0::true
19884:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::15969::-rr::363::CONSUME::3974::1::-293.4584358657012::-0.0::true
19887:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::15970::-rr::363::CONSUME::3980::1::-293.4584358657012::-0.0::true
19889:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::15971::-rr::363::CONSUME::3986::1::-293.4584358657012::-0.0::true
19890:org.powertac.common.DistributionTransaction::15976::-rr::363::4::0::0.0::-0.06
19890:org.powertac.common.CashPosition::15978::-rr::363::-1844.4618966807566
19890:org.powertac.common.msg.DistributionReport::15981::-rr::363::48812.69370000001::7048.27
20117:org.powertac.common.MarketPosition::200000037::new::0::387::0.0
20117:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000038::new::0::200000027::0.3::0.2
20117:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000039::new::0::200000027::-0.3::-0.2
24781:org.powertac.common.TimeService::null::setCurrentTime::2009-10-25T04:00:00.000Z
24858:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingControlEvent::19023::-rr::200000027::-4564.81242845107::-77.6529460762089::364
24878:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::18633::-rr::364::CONSUME::3968::1::-0.0::0.0::false
24879:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::18636::-rr::364::CONSUME::3974::1::-0.0::0.0::false
24880:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::18639::-rr::364::CONSUME::3980::1::-0.0::0.0::false
24880:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::18642::-rr::364::CONSUME::3986::1::-0.0::0.0::false
24881:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::19019::-rr::364::CONSUME::3968::1::-1141.2031071127676::-0.0::true
24881:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::19020::-rr::364::CONSUME::3974::1::-1141.2031071127676::-0.0::true
24882:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::19021::-rr::364::CONSUME::3980::1::-1141.2031071127676::-0.0::true
24882:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::19022::-rr::364::CONSUME::3986::1::-1141.2031071127676::-0.0::true
24882:org.powertac.common.DistributionTransaction::19027::-rr::364::4::0::0.0::-0.06
24883:org.powertac.common.CashPosition::19029::-rr::364::-1844.5218966807565
24883:org.powertac.common.msg.DistributionReport::19032::-rr::364::56721.12820000001::5126.05
25177:org.powertac.common.MarketPosition::200000040::new::0::388::0.0
25177:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000041::new::0::200000027::0.3::0.2
25178:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000042::new::0::200000027::-0.3::-0.2
29781:org.powertac.common.TimeService::null::setCurrentTime::2009-10-25T05:00:00.000Z
29855:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingControlEvent::22033::-rr::200000027::-10033.745265439858::-52.15766478517883::365
29874:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::21643::-rr::365::CONSUME::3968::1::-0.0::0.0::false
29874:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::21646::-rr::365::CONSUME::3974::1::-0.0::0.0::false
29876:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::21649::-rr::365::CONSUME::3980::1::-0.0::0.0::false
29876:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::21652::-rr::365::CONSUME::3986::1::-0.0::0.0::false
29877:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::22029::-rr::365::CONSUME::3968::1::-2508.4363163599646::-0.0::true
29877:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::22030::-rr::365::CONSUME::3974::1::-2508.4363163599646::-0.0::true
29877:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::22031::-rr::365::CONSUME::3980::1::-2508.4363163599646::-0.0::true
29878:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::22032::-rr::365::CONSUME::3986::1::-2508.4363163599646::-0.0::true
29878:org.powertac.common.DistributionTransaction::22037::-rr::365::4::0::0.0::-0.06
29878:org.powertac.common.CashPosition::22039::-rr::365::-1844.5818966807565
29879:org.powertac.common.msg.DistributionReport::22042::-rr::365::67469.50309999999::7087.45
30028:org.powertac.common.MarketPosition::200000043::new::0::389::0.0
30028:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000044::new::0::200000027::0.3::0.2
30028:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000045::new::0::200000027::-0.3::-0.2
34783:org.powertac.common.TimeService::null::setCurrentTime::2009-10-25T06:00:00.000Z
34859:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingControlEvent::25046::-rr::200000027::-18339.957721135805::63.75327797187698::366
34883:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::24656::-rr::366::CONSUME::3968::1::-0.0::0.0::false
34883:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::24659::-rr::366::CONSUME::3974::1::-0.0::0.0::false
34884:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::24662::-rr::366::CONSUME::3980::1::-0.0::0.0::false
34884:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::24665::-rr::366::CONSUME::3986::1::-0.0::0.0::false
34884:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::25042::-rr::366::CONSUME::3968::1::-4584.989430283951::-0.0::true
34885:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::25043::-rr::366::CONSUME::3974::1::-4584.989430283951::-0.0::true
34885:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::25044::-rr::366::CONSUME::3980::1::-4584.989430283951::-0.0::true
34886:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::25045::-rr::366::CONSUME::3986::1::-4584.989430283951::-0.0::true
34886:org.powertac.common.DistributionTransaction::25050::-rr::366::4::0::0.0::-0.06
34887:org.powertac.common.CashPosition::25052::-rr::366::-1844.6418966807564
34887:org.powertac.common.msg.DistributionReport::25055::-rr::366::64532.92040000003::9116.5
35147:org.powertac.common.MarketPosition::200000046::new::0::390::0.0
35147:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000047::new::0::200000027::0.3::0.2
35147:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000048::new::0::200000027::-0.3::-0.2
39781:org.powertac.common.TimeService::null::setCurrentTime::2009-10-25T07:00:00.000Z
39863:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingControlEvent::28042::-rr::200000027::-20000.0::343.9812943098561::367
39923:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::27652::-rr::367::CONSUME::3968::1::-0.0::0.0::false
39923:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::27655::-rr::367::CONSUME::3974::1::-0.0::0.0::false
39924:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::27658::-rr::367::CONSUME::3980::1::-0.0::0.0::false
39924:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::27661::-rr::367::CONSUME::3986::1::-0.0::0.0::false
39924:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::28038::-rr::367::CONSUME::3968::1::-5000.0::-0.0::true
39925:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::28039::-rr::367::CONSUME::3974::1::-5000.0::-0.0::true
39925:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::28040::-rr::367::CONSUME::3980::1::-5000.0::-0.0::true
39925:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::28041::-rr::367::CONSUME::3986::1::-5000.0::-0.0::true
39926:org.powertac.common.DistributionTransaction::28202::-rr::367::4::0::0.0::-0.06
39926:org.powertac.common.CashPosition::28204::-rr::367::-1844.7018966807564
39926:org.powertac.common.msg.DistributionReport::28207::-rr::367::78102.02279821024::19065.54
40147:org.powertac.common.MarketPosition::200000049::new::0::391::0.0
40147:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000050::new::0::200000027::0.3::0.2
40147:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000051::new::0::200000027::-0.3::-0.2
44781:org.powertac.common.TimeService::null::setCurrentTime::2009-10-25T08:00:00.000Z
44869:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingControlEvent::31191::-rr::200000027::-20000.0::1167.705608477612::368
44887:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::30801::-rr::368::CONSUME::3968::1::-0.0::0.0::false
44887:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::30804::-rr::368::CONSUME::3974::1::-0.0::0.0::false
44888:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::30807::-rr::368::CONSUME::3980::1::-0.0::0.0::false
44888:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::30810::-rr::368::CONSUME::3986::1::-0.0::0.0::false
44888:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::31187::-rr::368::CONSUME::3968::1::-5000.0::-0.0::true
44889:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::31188::-rr::368::CONSUME::3974::1::-5000.0::-0.0::true
44889:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::31189::-rr::368::CONSUME::3980::1::-5000.0::-0.0::true
44889:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::31190::-rr::368::CONSUME::3986::1::-5000.0::-0.0::true
44890:org.powertac.common.DistributionTransaction::31195::-rr::368::4::0::0.0::-0.06
44892:org.powertac.common.CashPosition::31197::-rr::368::-1844.7618966807563
44892:org.powertac.common.msg.DistributionReport::31200::-rr::368::77275.60203402909::34134.86
45103:org.powertac.common.MarketPosition::200000052::new::0::392::0.0
45103:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000053::new::0::200000027::0.3::0.2
45103:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000054::new::0::200000027::-0.3::-0.2
49784:org.powertac.common.TimeService::null::setCurrentTime::2009-10-25T09:00:00.000Z
49874:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingControlEvent::34168::-rr::200000027::-20000.0::334.10469553647147::369
49893:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::33778::-rr::369::CONSUME::3968::1::-0.0::0.0::false
49893:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::33781::-rr::369::CONSUME::3974::1::-0.0::0.0::false
49894:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::33784::-rr::369::CONSUME::3980::1::-0.0::0.0::false
49894:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::33787::-rr::369::CONSUME::3986::1::-0.0::0.0::false
49895:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::34164::-rr::369::CONSUME::3968::1::-5000.0::-0.0::true
49895:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::34165::-rr::369::CONSUME::3974::1::-5000.0::-0.0::true
49896:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::34166::-rr::369::CONSUME::3980::1::-5000.0::-0.0::true
49896:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::34167::-rr::369::CONSUME::3986::1::-5000.0::-0.0::true
49900:org.powertac.common.DistributionTransaction::34172::-rr::369::4::0::0.0::-0.06
49901:org.powertac.common.CashPosition::34174::-rr::369::-1844.8218966807563
49901:org.powertac.common.msg.DistributionReport::34177::-rr::369::72461.45151097218::31302.03
50070:org.powertac.common.MarketPosition::200000055::new::0::393::0.0
50070:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000056::new::0::200000027::0.3::0.2
50070:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000057::new::0::200000027::-0.3::-0.2
54782:org.powertac.common.TimeService::null::setCurrentTime::2009-10-25T10:00:00.000Z
54850:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingControlEvent::37138::-rr::200000027::-20000.0::511.31842133296084::370
54868:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::36748::-rr::370::CONSUME::3968::1::-0.0::0.0::false
54868:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::36751::-rr::370::CONSUME::3974::1::-0.0::0.0::false
54868:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::36754::-rr::370::CONSUME::3980::1::-0.0::0.0::false
54869:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::36757::-rr::370::CONSUME::3986::1::-0.0::0.0::false
54869:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::37134::-rr::370::CONSUME::3968::1::-5000.0::-0.0::true
54869:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::37135::-rr::370::CONSUME::3974::1::-5000.0::-0.0::true
54870:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::37136::-rr::370::CONSUME::3980::1::-5000.0::-0.0::true
54870:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::37137::-rr::370::CONSUME::3986::1::-5000.0::-0.0::true
54871:org.powertac.common.DistributionTransaction::37142::-rr::370::4::0::0.0::-0.06
54871:org.powertac.common.CashPosition::37144::-rr::370::-1844.8818966807562
54871:org.powertac.common.msg.DistributionReport::37147::-rr::370::71058.97396346138::26854.010000000002
55018:org.powertac.common.MarketPosition::200000058::new::0::394::0.0
55018:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000059::new::0::200000027::0.3::0.2
55018:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000060::new::0::200000027::-0.3::-0.2
59782:org.powertac.common.TimeService::null::setCurrentTime::2009-10-25T11:00:00.000Z
59853:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingControlEvent::40118::-rr::200000027::-16966.081306654785::247.6910585084024::371
59871:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::39728::-rr::371::CONSUME::3968::1::-0.0::0.0::false
59872:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::39731::-rr::371::CONSUME::3974::1::-0.0::0.0::false
59872:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::39734::-rr::371::CONSUME::3980::1::-0.0::0.0::false
59873:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::39737::-rr::371::CONSUME::3986::1::-0.0::0.0::false
59874:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::40114::-rr::371::CONSUME::3968::1::-4241.520326663696::-0.0::true
59874:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::40115::-rr::371::CONSUME::3974::1::-4241.520326663696::-0.0::true
59874:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::40116::-rr::371::CONSUME::3980::1::-4241.520326663696::-0.0::true
59875:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::40117::-rr::371::CONSUME::3986::1::-4241.520326663696::-0.0::true
59875:org.powertac.common.DistributionTransaction::40122::-rr::371::4::0::0.0::-0.06
59875:org.powertac.common.CashPosition::40124::-rr::371::-1844.9418966807561
59876:org.powertac.common.msg.DistributionReport::40127::-rr::371::66979.28782693313::19087.77
60104:org.powertac.common.MarketPosition::200000061::new::0::395::0.0
60104:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000062::new::0::200000027::0.3::0.2
60105:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000063::new::0::200000027::-0.3::-0.2
64782:org.powertac.common.TimeService::null::setCurrentTime::2009-10-25T12:00:00.000Z
64867:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::42685::-rr::372::CONSUME::3968::1::-0.0::0.0::false
64867:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::42688::-rr::372::CONSUME::3974::1::-0.0::0.0::false
64868:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::42691::-rr::372::CONSUME::3980::1::-0.0::0.0::false
64868:org.powertac.common.TariffTransaction::42694::-rr::372::CONSUME::3986::1::-0.0::0.0::false
64868:org.powertac.common.DistributionTransaction::43070::-rr::372::4::0::0.0::-0.06
64869:org.powertac.common.CashPosition::43072::-rr::372::-1845.001896680756
64869:org.powertac.common.msg.DistributionReport::43075::-rr::372::50952.718059795385::14549.470000000001
65031:org.powertac.common.MarketPosition::200000064::new::0::396::0.0
65031:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000065::new::0::200000027::0.3::0.2
65031:org.powertac.common.msg.BalancingOrder::200000066::new::0::200000027::-0.3::-0.2
69781:org.powertac.common.TimeService::null::setCurrentTime::2009-10-25T13:00:00.000Z
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|  
Report Content as Inappropriate

Re: Announcement: Power TAC server and sample broker version 1.3.3

serkan
And I use a new type of tariff. Maybe this is triggering the problem?
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|  
Report Content as Inappropriate

Re: Issue 889

grampajohn
Administrator
serkan wrote
And I use a new type of tariff. Maybe this is triggering the problem?
No, it's simply that the BalancingControlEvent is not being forwarded to Accounting as it should be. We missed an important test case.

John
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|  
Report Content as Inappropriate

Re: Issue 889

grampajohn
Administrator
Serkan and all -
grampajohn wrote
No, it's simply that the BalancingControlEvent is not being forwarded to Accounting as it should be. We missed an important test case.
The accounting is in fact correct in the current server, but it's done by issuing additional TariffTransaction messages, rather than accounting for the BCE separately. This is because the BCE is issued against a tariff, not a customer, and brokers presumably need to know energy and payment info by customer rather than just by tariff. These transactions will have the isRegulation flag set to true.

Does this help?

John
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|  
Report Content as Inappropriate

Re: Issue 889

serkan
This post was updated on .
I see those (with true flag) as transactions between customers and brokers and they are subject to up and down regulation prices, specified in the tariff. But I can not see any other transaction (between broker and BM).

As said, I set up and down regulation prices to 0.0 in the tariff and this is what I see after trading 30 MWh in the balancing market.



Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|  
Report Content as Inappropriate

Re: Issue 889

serkan
All I can see is a bce transaction, which is actually enough for me to play around it.
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|  
Report Content as Inappropriate

Re: Issue 889

grampajohn
Administrator
In reply to this post by serkan
Hello, Serkan -
serkan wrote
I see those (with true flag) as transactions between customers and brokers and they are subject to up and down regulation prices, specified in the tariff. But I can not see any other transaction (between broker and BM).
OK, now I think I understand the problem. We are giving you the payments between you and the customer, but not the settlement in the balancing market. I'll re-open #889 and look into it.

John
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|  
Report Content as Inappropriate

Re: Issue 889

grampajohn
Administrator
In reply to this post by serkan
serkan wrote
All I can see is a bce transaction.
The BalancingTransaction aggregates balancing-market payments across all tariffs. So at this point, you can see how much you paid for balancing, and how much you pay your customers for the use of their demand-response resources. What you cannot see is the demand-response payments from the balancing market, broken down by tariff. How important is that?

John
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|  
Report Content as Inappropriate

Re: Issue 889

serkan
grampajohn wrote
What you cannot see is the demand-response payments from the balancing market, broken down by tariff. How important is that?
I think, aggregated BM report should be sufficient. The only problem is that balancing market payment is not added to the cash position whereas its corresponding customer transaction (as CONSUME or PRODUCE) is added as contracted in the tariff (up-down regulation price). In the end, this payment is an incentive and brokers must be rewarded for bothering themselves.
Loading...